WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court has ruled that prediction-market operator Kalshi cannot use federal derivatives law to escape Maryland’s gambling laws, according to Better Markets, a nonprofit financial-reform advocacy group that weighed in on the case.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit issued the decision Tuesday, Nov. 17, in KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, the group said. Better Markets said the three-judge panel produced three separate opinions and that the outcome matches earlier rulings by the 6th and 9th circuits.
“The Fourth Circuit got it right, just as the Sixth and Ninth Circuits did before it,” said Dominick Freda, the group’s legal director.
Freda said the split opinions should not be read as a sign the legal question is close. “The judges in the majority just couldn’t agree on which of Kalshi’s arguments to avoid state gambling laws was worse,” he said. “It was a sports bet before Kalshi, and it is a sports bet now.”
Better Markets, which filed a friend-of-the-court brief with the 4th Circuit in December 2025, argued that Kalshi’s legal strategy depends on treating wagers on games as derivatives so the company can claim the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and sidestep state gambling laws nationwide.
The group contends that swaps exist so businesses and investors can manage genuine financial risks, such as swings in interest rates, commodity prices and currencies, and that regulating gambling has traditionally been left to the states.
“Nobody really thinks that betting on Josh Allen’s passing yards or LeBron James’ number of threes in the fourth quarter of a game is hedging risk,” Freda said.
A day after the ruling, Better Markets also filed a comment letter urging the CFTC to withdraw proposals that would define event contracts on sporting events as swaps while treating sportsbook wagers differently, according to the group.
New Jersey is among the states that license and regulate sports betting.
This report is based on information from Better Markets.
Source: Better Markets







Leave a Reply