WASHINGTON — U.S. home insurers took in an estimated $113 billion more in underwriting income from 2021 through 2025 than they would have if they had been required to pay out at least 80 cents in claims for every premium dollar, according to a report released Thursday by three consumer and government watchdog groups.
The report, issued jointly by Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, the Revolving Door Project and Public Citizen, draws on market data published by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, the organization that coordinates state insurance regulators, the groups said.
According to the report, insurers collected $181.2 billion in homeowners premiums in 2025, up 59% from $113.9 billion in 2021. Over the same period, claims payouts rose 28%, from $78.4 billion to just over $100 billion, the groups said.
As a result, the share of premium dollars returned to policyholders as claims, known as the loss ratio, fell from 68.8% in 2021 to 55.1% in 2025, the report found. The groups said that figure averaged about 74% in the 1990s.
The report also said insurers closed roughly 30% of homeowners claims without any payment from 2021 through 2025, and that more than 22% of the claims they did pay took longer than 60 days to settle.
The groups argued that higher premiums cannot be fully explained by climate-related losses, reinsurance costs or construction prices. They blamed spending on executive pay, advertising and shareholder dividends, along with what they described as record profits. The report noted that insurers have attributed rate increases and market withdrawals to more frequent and costly disasters.
The $113 billion figure compares actual results with a hypothetical rule requiring insurers to spend at least 80% of premiums on claims, a standard the groups likened to federal requirements for health insurers.
The report examined Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine and Florida in detail. In Texas, it said, insurers collected 78% more in premiums in 2025 than in 2021 while claims payouts fell 23%. The groups said Liberty Mutual’s largest home insurance company in Texas raised its rates by a cumulative 144% over the period with little objection from the state regulator.
“Home insurers are simultaneously overcharging and short-changing households as the fossil fuel-driven climate crisis intensifies,” said Kenny Stancil, deputy research director at the Revolving Door Project.
“Insurance companies are maximizing profits by raising rates, withdrawing from communities, and closing a staggering number of claims without payment,” said Elyse Schupak, a policy advocate with Public Citizen’s Climate Program.
“Families are paying too much for home insurance and getting less back when climate disasters strike,” said Alex Martin, climate finance policy director at Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund.
The groups called on regulators and lawmakers to weigh loss-ratio trends when reviewing rate increases, require insurers to invest in and reward climate resilience, and make underwriting, pricing and claims decisions more transparent to consumers.
Homeowners insurance rates in the United States are regulated by the states rather than the federal government.
This report is based on information from Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, the Revolving Door Project and Public Citizen.
Source: Revolving Door Project







Leave a Reply