Hundreds of disciplinary cases, documented civil rights violations, and continuing restrictions on independent civilian investigations show the substantial work remaining in New Jersey’s effort to curb police corruption and misconduct, civil rights advocates say.
State records show 169 law enforcement agencies reported 817 major disciplinary actions involving 654 officers in 2025. The disclosures offer a measure of public accountability, but advocates argue that publishing misconduct after it occurs cannot substitute for giving communities greater power to investigate it.
At the center of that debate is a legislative proposal to let municipalities and counties establish civilian review boards with subpoena power, allowing them to compel testimony and obtain documents.
The Governor and Attorney General appear to be against that.
Supporters say those powers are essential to independent oversight of officers authorized to stop, search, arrest, and use force against the public.
Six years after the New Jersey Supreme Court restricted the powers of Newark’s Civilian Complaint Review Board, that authority remains an unfinished legislative priority.
The Legislature’s latest proposal, S2832, has languished in the Senate Law and Public Safety Committee since it was introduced by Senator Shirley K. Turner on Jan. 13, 2026.
Identical legislation has been introduced every session since September 2020, the month after the state Supreme Court stripped Newark’s civilian complaint review board of subpoena powers, but Assemblywoman Verlina Reynolds-Jackson and Turner either don’t care about it, or they lack the clout to shepherd the measure into law.
Governor Rebecca ‘Mikie’ Sherrill told police unions during her victorious campaign that she opposed giving civilian boards subpoena powers, a stance that, if maintained, could doom the chances of statewide reform.
The 31st annual nationwide observance of the Day of Protest Against Police Brutality took place on October 22, 2026, with demonstrations led by People’s Organization for Progress Chairman Lawrence Hamm, who has spent decades advocating for civilian complaint review boards (CCRBs) with subpoena power.
Hamm criticized the state’s Democratic majorities for failing to advance a wide range of legislation critical to minority communities, including the police misconduct panels.
He also called it a “disgrace” that a bill to establish a reparations task force had remained stalled in committee for years despite Democrats controlling the Assembly, Senate, and Governor’s office.
The American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey and Newark Communities for Accountable Policing have pressed for permanent, independent civilian oversight.
In a July assessment, the ACLU acknowledged substantial improvements in Newark while warning that the work of ensuring accountability remains incomplete.
Discipline disclosures reveal the scope of misconduct
The 2025 disclosures covered the largest annual number of officers reported since New Jersey expanded its discipline reporting requirements in 2020, according to the New Jersey Monitor.
The cases involved law enforcement personnel across agencies, including corrections officers, rather than municipal police alone.
Major discipline generally includes termination, demotion or suspension for more than five days. Reporting requirements also encompass certain criminal charges and departures during pending investigations. The figures therefore should not be read as a count of criminal convictions or treated as interchangeable with the number of offenses.
One case involved former Manville Police Chief Thomas Herbst, who was sentenced to seven years in state prison in August 2025 following convictions for sexual assault, official misconduct and criminal sexual contact.
The attorney general’s office described conduct that victimized subordinates over more than a decade.
Such prosecutions demonstrate that state authorities can hold officers accountable. The broader oversight question is whether existing safeguards identify abuse early enough to prevent repeated harm.
Federal investigators documented that problem in Trenton. In November 2024, the Justice Department found reasonable cause to believe the city’s police department engaged in a pattern or practice of excessive force and unlawful stops, searches, and arrests.
Investigators also identified persistent failures in accountability, supervision, and training that contributed to constitutional violations.
In one encounter described by investigators, an officer repeatedly stomped on a man’s hand, knelt on his head and kicked his shoulder after he was on the ground. The Justice Department said Trenton had spent more than $7 million since 2021 resolving lawsuits involving allegations of officer misconduct.
Civilian investigations face legal limits
Newark’s experience illustrates both the potential for reform and the limits on local oversight.
A federal investigation released in 2014 found unconstitutional policing, excessive force and theft by officers, along with deficiencies in systems intended to prevent and detect misconduct. A court-approved consent decree followed in 2016. Newark also established its civilian review board by ordinance that year.
The Fraternal Order of Police’s Newark lodge challenged the board’s authority. In its August 2020 decision, the state Supreme Court upheld the city’s ability to establish a civilian board but invalidated its subpoena power under existing law.
The court also barred the board from investigating a complaint while the police department’s internal affairs unit conducted a concurrent investigation. It permitted independent investigations when no internal affairs investigation was underway, as well as broader reviews of departmental operations and recommendations for discipline.
The ruling left lawmakers responsible for authorizing stronger investigative powers.
S2832 would allow civilian boards to subpoena witnesses and documents and conduct investigations alongside internal affairs units. Boards would recommend discipline consistent with civil service protections and contractual agreements.
The proposal also contains restrictions intended to protect related criminal proceedings. A board’s investigation would have to stop when a criminal prosecution began. Law enforcement agencies could withhold evidence or direct a board to halt an investigation if a related criminal inquiry created a significant risk to the disciplinary process.
Progress leaves continuing obligations
Newark has made documented progress. A federal judge terminated its consent decree in November 2025 after finding that durable reforms had addressed the conditions underlying federal intervention. The Justice Department supported ending the decree.
Those changes included stronger use-of-force policies, body camera requirements, and protections against discriminatory policing, according to the ACLU of New Jersey.
The organization nevertheless maintains that lasting accountability requires continued training, monitoring, and meaningful community oversight.
Attorney General Jennifer Davenport proposed stronger investigations of sexual abuse and other misconduct by pharmacists, social workers, massage therapists, veterinarians, accountants, electricians, plumbers, funeral directors, and cosmetologists.
She has not sought to empower civilian complaint review boards that investigate official corruption, police brutality, or similar misconduct.
Instead, Davenport abolished the standalone Office of Public Integrity and Accountability, transferring its investigators and prosecutors to the Division of Criminal Justice.
Stronger civilian oversight of police remains unfinished business.
For reform advocates, the remaining challenge is to make accountability a routine safeguard rather than a response to years of abuse. New Jersey now publishes more information about officer misconduct, but the proposed authority for civilians to compel evidence in their own investigations remains before the Legislature.







Leave a Reply