Sen. Ron Johnson calls Social Security a ‘scam,’ says it should be shut down

The hands of an older person

WASHINGTON — Republican Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin called Social Security a “scam” and a “Ponzi scheme” on Wednesday. He said the program cannot be repaired and should be shut down, comments that drew sharp criticism from retiree advocates, economists and Senate Democrats.

Johnson spoke during a morning interview on Fox Business. He said there was no longer any way to fix the program and that the government should “shut it down” and try to recover some of the money workers have paid in.

The remarks came hours before Johnson opened a Senate Budget Committee hearing titled “Social Security: The Reality.” He said the hearing would show that the program has been grossly mismanaged.

Social Security is not a Ponzi scheme in any legal or technical sense. It is a pay-as-you-go social insurance program created by Congress. Payroll taxes on current workers fund benefits for current retirees, survivors and people with disabilities, and the program’s finances are reported publicly each year by its trustees. Those trustees have projected that unless Congress acts, the program’s trust funds will run out in the mid-2030s. After that, incoming payroll taxes would still cover roughly 80% of scheduled benefits.

Johnson has used the “Ponzi scheme” label since his first Senate campaign in 2010. He is up for reelection in 2028 in Wisconsin, a swing state where more than a million residents receive Social Security benefits.

Social Security Works, a progressive advocacy group, quickly condemned the comments in a social media post.

“Social Security is the most popular and effective program in America. Ron Johnson wants to ‘shut it down.’ And any Republicans who won’t commit to making billionaires pay their fair share agrees with him,” the group said.

Nancy Altman, the group’s president, called Johnson’s proposal an effort “to steal Americans’ earned benefits.” She said Johnson, whose net worth her group estimates at $40 million, would still have a secure retirement if the program ended. Millions of older Americans and people with disabilities, she said, would face hunger and homelessness.

Economists also disputed Johnson’s claim that the program cannot be fixed. Stephen Nuñez of the Roosevelt Institute said the shortfall comes from the program’s limited funding structure, some missed actuarial projections and lawmakers’ failure to act. He said there is no collapse on the horizon. Matt Darling, a policy fellow at the Searchlight Institute, said the worst realistic outcome is a program that pays about 80% of promised benefits.

Several Senate Democrats also criticized Johnson. Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon said it had been decades since a senior senator said he would rather end Social Security than repair it.

Policy analyst Ned Resnikoff noted that President George W. Bush’s push to partially privatize Social Security after the 2004 election stalled and hurt Republicans politically. He suggested Johnson’s comments could carry similar risks.

Congress last made major changes to Social Security’s finances in 1983. Those changes followed a bipartisan commission’s recommendations to address a funding crisis. Proposals now under discussion include raising or removing the cap on wages subject to payroll taxes, raising the tax rate, adjusting benefits, or some combination of these.

Common Dreams first reported Johnson’s remarks.

Advertisement

physicians-mutual-dental-insurance-banners
generac-home-standby-generator-banners
liz-buys-houses-digital
liz-buys-houses-digital
physicians-mutual-dental-insurance-banners

Gift this article