WASHINGTON — The financial reform group Better Markets on Wednesday praised a federal appeals court ruling that prediction-market operator Kalshi cannot rely on federal derivatives law to avoid Maryland’s gambling regulations.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit ruled Tuesday in KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, according to the group, which had filed a friend-of-the-court brief in the case supporting Maryland’s position. Better Markets said the decision aligns with earlier rulings from the 6th and 9th circuits.
Kalshi, an exchange regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, offers contracts on the outcomes of sporting events. The company has argued that those contracts are swaps under the CFTC’s exclusive federal jurisdiction, which would place them beyond the reach of state gambling laws.
“The Fourth Circuit got it right, just as the Sixth and Ninth Circuits did before it,” said Dominick Freda, the group’s legal director. “But no one should mistake a three-judge panel writing three separate opinions for a sign that this is a hard question. It isn’t.”
Freda said the judges in the majority disagreed only over which of Kalshi’s arguments was weakest. “A bet on who wins Sunday’s game is a sports bet,” he said. “Calling it a ‘swap’ or an ‘event contract’ doesn’t change what it is.”
In its brief, Better Markets argued that swaps exist to help businesses and investors manage genuine financial risks, such as movements in interest rates, commodity prices and currencies, and that wagers on individual athletes’ performances serve no such purpose. The group said regulating gambling has always been the job of the states.
“Kalshi can keep repackaging its product and asking judges to ignore what everyone can see, but the courts are seeing through it,” Freda said.
Better Markets describes itself as a nonprofit, nonpartisan economic advocacy organization focused on financial regulation. New Jersey gaming regulators have also been in litigation with Kalshi over whether states may regulate its sports contracts.
This report is based on information from Better Markets.
Source: Better Markets







Leave a Reply