A veteran election administrator says American elections are “easy to vote, hard to cheat,” pointing to the nation’s decentralized system of thousands of locally run elections as a core safeguard against widespread fraud.

But critics argue the opposite: that Republicans have manufactured the myth of voter fraud to justify laws that make voting harder and to seize control of election administration.

Leslie Reynolds, who spent 26 years leading the National Association of Secretaries of State and now serves as a senior advisor, said in an interview for “The Good Government Show” that the biggest challenge facing election administration is not fraud but public misunderstanding. “People don’t know how elections work,” she said.

Her argument rests on structure. Rather than a single national system, elections are administered by states and thousands of local jurisdictions with varying rules, equipment and oversight. “It’s very difficult to rig an election when it’s run 8,000 different ways,” Reynolds said, summarizing the association’s philosophy as “easy to vote, hard to cheat.”

She suggested skeptics become poll workers. “If you don’t understand the process, go become a poll worker,” she said.

A Contested Claim

Not everyone agrees the system is resistant to manipulation. In a January 2026 opinion piece for the Milwaukee Independent, writer Mitchell A. Sobieski argued that the myth of mass voter fraud “endures as one of the most effective tools for modern voter suppression.”

Sobieski traced the strategy to the post-Civil Rights era, when new laws enfranchised millions of Black voters and conservative activists began reframing that progress as a threat to “honest elections.” The phrase “ballot security” became a coded justification for aggressive poll monitoring and voter roll purges, he wrote.

“Studies by the Brennan Center for Justice, the Associated Press, and state election commissions have repeatedly shown that cases of intentional fraud account for a fraction of one percent of ballots cast,” Sobieski wrote. In Wisconsin, he said, audits have confirmed the state’s election system is secure and irregularities are rare and typically administrative, not criminal.

He argued that the 2020 election transformed the narrative into a national movement, with Wisconsin becoming a primary battleground. Conservative lawmakers launched investigations that turned up no proof of widespread fraud, but the political damage was lasting, he wrote.

“By repeating baseless allegations, the right sowed distrust among its own voters while creating pretexts for new restrictions on everyone else,” Sobieski wrote.

Restrictions and Administration

Sobieski cited strict voter ID requirements, limits on absentee voting and aggressive roll purges as measures that disproportionately affect poor, urban and minority voters. In Milwaukee, he said, such measures intersect with economic and racial disparities, where reliable access to transportation, identification and flexible work hours cannot be assumed.

He also argued that Republican lawmakers in multiple states have sought to strip local election commissions of authority, replacing professional oversight with partisan control. In Wisconsin, he said, bills have aimed to reduce the autonomy of the bipartisan Wisconsin Elections Commission, transferring power back to the Legislature. Similar movements have occurred in Georgia, Arizona and Texas, he wrote.

“The pattern suggests a strategic national agenda,” Sobieski wrote. “If local election officials cannot be discredited, then they must be replaced.”

Meanwhile, Democrats have responded with initiatives aimed at expanding access, including automatic voter registration, extended early voting and public education campaigns. In Wisconsin, Gov. Tony Evers and Democratic lawmakers have consistently vetoed Republican proposals that would make voting more restrictive, Sobieski wrote.

Data and Threats

Data from analyses of recent elections generally shows voter fraud is rare. A Brookings Institution review of mail voting fraud cases across the 2016, 2018, 2020 and 2022 general elections found an average fraud rate of roughly 0.000043% — about four cases per every 10 million mail ballots cast. The American Bar Association, citing analyses of over 25 million votes in six swing states in 2020, found fewer than 475 potential fraud cases, none confirmed to have altered an outcome.

Nearly 98% of votes cast in the 2024 general election were on paper or had a voter-verifiable paper trail, allowing for post-election audits.

Reynolds’ organization has separately condemned threats against election officials, saying in an October 2026 joint statement that “threats against election officials and workers have no place in our democracy.”

Dave Martin, host of “The Good Government Show,” said Reynolds’ message is that anyone can participate. “If you want to see how elections work, work one,” he said.

Advertisement

physicians-mutual-dental-insurance-banners
generac-home-standby-generator-banners
liz-buys-houses-digital
liz-buys-houses-digital
physicians-mutual-dental-insurance-banners

Gift this article