A real estate for sale sign

WASHINGTON — U.S. home insurers collected an estimated $113 billion more in underwriting income from 2021 through 2025 than they would have under an 80% minimum payout standard, according to a report released Thursday by three progressive advocacy groups.

The report, issued Nov. 19 by Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, the Revolving Door Project and Public Citizen, argues that rising climate losses, reinsurance costs and construction prices do not fully account for the steep climb in homeowners’ premiums. The groups contend that insurer profits and overhead, including executive pay, advertising and shareholder dividends, also drove prices higher.

Drawing on National Association of Insurance Commissioners data, the groups said premiums collected on homeowner policies rose 59% over the five-year period, from about $113.9 billion in 2021 to $181.2 billion in 2025, while claims payouts increased 28%, from $78.4 billion to just over $100 billion.

As a result, the report said, insurers paid out roughly 55 cents in claims for every premium dollar in 2025, down from 69 cents in 2021. The groups noted that home insurance loss ratios averaged about 74% in the 1990s.

The analysis also found that insurers closed about 30% of claims without any payment between 2021 and 2025, and that more than 22% of paid claims took longer than 60 days to settle, according to the groups.

The $113 billion figure is the groups’ own estimate. It compares insurers’ actual underwriting income with what they would have earned if claims had equaled at least 80% of premiums, a benchmark the report attributes to a Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator researcher and likens to federal medical loss ratio rules for health insurers.

The report examined five states in detail: Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine and Florida. In Texas, the groups said, premiums collected rose 78% from 2021 to 2025 while claims payouts fell 23%, and Liberty Mutual’s largest home insurance company in the state raised rates by a cumulative 144% with little objection from regulators.

“Home insurers are simultaneously overcharging and short-changing households as the fossil fuel-driven climate crisis intensifies,” said Kenny Stancil, deputy research director at the Revolving Door Project.

Alex Martin, climate finance policy director at Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, said regulators and policymakers “should take action now to stop families from being forced to pay more for less.”

The groups recommended that state regulators weigh past loss ratios when reviewing rate increases, require insurers to invest in and reward climate resilience, step up oversight of claims handling and make underwriting and pricing decisions more transparent to consumers.

The insurance industry has long attributed rising premiums to more frequent and costly natural disasters, higher reinsurance costs and inflation. Home insurance in the United States is regulated by the states.

This report is based on information from the Revolving Door Project.

Source: Revolving Door Project

Advertisement

physicians-mutual-dental-insurance-banners
generac-home-standby-generator-banners
liz-buys-houses-digital
liz-buys-houses-digital
physicians-mutual-dental-insurance-banners

Gift this article